Vincent D'Onofrio
as
Father Casey
Emile Hirsch
as
Francis Doyle
Jena Malone
as
Margie Flynn
Jodie Foster
as
Sister Assumpta
J.B. Rogers
Director
Celia Weston
as
Jane
Jay Johnston
as
Kline
Sean Astin
as
Mike
Cathy Shim
as
Olivia
Mayko Nguyen
as
Caroline
Sugar Lyn Beard
as
Mary
Tony Nappo
as
Paul
Joe Adler
as
Nathan Nesbitt
Pierson Fode
as
Ryan
Michael Welch
as
Tim
Alastair Sim
as
Deniston Russell
George Cole
as
Herbert Russell
Michael Beasley
as
Kitchen Staffer
R. Keith Harris
as
Seton Motley
Ethan Embry
as
Doyle Standish
Patrika Darbo
as
Greasy Spoon Waitress
L. Scott Caldwell
as
Homeless Woman
J.C. MacKenzie
as
Mike Malloy
Joel Nagle
as
Karl
Michelle Randolph
as
Rachel
Darren Mann
as
Shane
Emmanuelle Chriqui
as
Claire Bonner
Carly Pope
as
Fawn
Jean Smart
as
Laura Brandston
Chris Elliott
as
Snowplowman
Marcus Natividad
as
Assassin Hitman
Mindy Robinson
as
Video Vixen
Michael Flores
as
Villain
David Cross
as
Self
Bobcat Goldthwait
as
Self
Dann Fink
as
Additional Voices
Marcella Lentz-Pope
as
Additional Voices
Brian Quinn
as
Q
Maggie Kiley
Director
Stefanie Scott
as
Allie
Mary B. McCann
as
Beth
Sam Page
as
Justin
Anna Camp
as
Sabrina
Michael Dinner
Director
Douglas Seale
as
Brother Domenic
John Heard
as
Brother Timothy
Wallace Shawn
as
Father Abruzzi
Mel Winkler
as
Willie
Reese Alexander
as
Jimmy
April Telek
as
Judy
Fiona Vroom
as
Penny
Omari Newton
as
Richie
Matthew Willig
as
El Caballo
Robert Miano
as
El Gato Enfermo
Erik Palladino
as
Texican